Leadership Challenges: How to Handle Employee Terminations

Terminating the employment of an individual whose conduct or job performance does not align with an organization’s values or performance expectations is a common challenge to those in leadership roles. Addressing such situations while maintaining the organization’s interests, upholding personal morals, and adhering to professional standards is a delicate balance every leader must find. This article will share advice and personal insights from INTA’s Leadership Development Committee (LDC) on how to handle the difficult task of employee terminations with professionalism and empathy.

The Last Resort

Before we come to the option of termination, it’s a leader’s responsibility to ensure that the employee clearly understands the company’s strategy, objectives, and performance metrics. Many LDC members note that it’s critical to set realistic expectations, offer performance feedback, as well as provide necessary coaching and training to enable an employee to achieve the best results. This also helps address any performance issues at an early stage as termination should always be the last resort after all alternative routes have been exhausted.

Be Prepared

 Before the termination meeting, gather all necessary documentation related to the employee’s performance issues or other factors leading to the decision. Ensure that the termination process complies with all relevant labor laws and company policies, including providing any required notice or documentation. After all, you wouldn’t want your lack of preparation to be the reason you end up having a conversation with Human Resources about “how not to fire people.”

Be Direct and Stick to the Facts

Start the conversation by clearly stating that the purpose of the meeting is to discuss the termination of the employee’s employment, thereby avoiding any ambiguity. As Catherine Hoffman from Baker Donelson says, keep it “simple, professional, and uncomplicated.” Further, clearly spell out the reason for the termination, separating performance and behavioral issues. Explain with examples during the interview what consequences the employee’s poor performance or behavior led to. This allows you to convey that the issue is business-related, not personal, and helps lead to a more constructive and cordial conversation, with lesser resistance.

Handle Logistics

Discuss logistical matters such as returning company property, final paycheck details, and any outstanding tasks or projects. At the end of the meeting, where possible, obtain the employee’s sign-off. After the meeting, document the details of the conversation, including the reasons for termination and any agreements or arrangements made.

Talk to Your Team

Terminating an employee from the organization is a challenging experience not only for the leader but also for the entire team. Serra Coral from Deris points out that the process can cause anxiety, disrupt team dynamics, and impact the team’s motivation. It’s therefore important to inform other team members of the termination without delay. To avoid rumors and speculations, as well as to protect the terminated employee’s privacy, this communication should be transparent and provide necessary context. The leaders should be prepared to address any concerns and reassure the team about job security and how to deal with the additional workload.

Different Styles of Leaders

Leaders may struggle with empathy during termination tasks, often exhibiting one of two tendencies: excessive empathy or lack thereof.

Overly Empathetic Leaders

It’s understandable to struggle with being overly empathetic in difficult situations, such as terminating employment. While empathy is valuable, it must be balanced with professionalism and the needs of the organization.

“I always felt regret about letting someone go. I think it’s human nature. It’s a decision that impacts someone’s livelihood,” an LDC member shared. “However, when dealing with feelings of regret, it’s helpful to keep the proper perspective and realize that in many situations, it’s the right and necessary outcome for both sides,” she added.

As leaders in a firm or company, we all have our organizational and personal goals. In the end, we must remind ourselves of the reasons behind the decision to terminate. Rather than getting caught up in the emotional aspects of the situation, approach it from a neutral standpoint, focusing on the facts and the organization’s needs. It’s okay to feel compassion for others, but it’s key to prioritize the needs of the organization and make decisions that are in its best interest.

Leaders Lacking Empathy

While some leaders may struggle with being overly empathetic, others find themselves on the opposite end of the spectrum—leaning towards a more detached and objective stance. If you find yourself in the latter category, here are some thoughtful suggestions to ensure a sufficiently compassionate approach.

Firstly, consider the setting for a termination meeting. It’s crucial to choose a location that provides privacy and minimizes interruptions. Timing is also key; scheduling the meeting towards the end of the day or week allows the employee some space to process the news without the immediate pressure of office dynamics or gossip.

During the meeting, it’s essential to acknowledge the gravity of the situation and recognize that this is a difficult time for the employee. Be transparent about any severance packages, continued benefits, or outplacement services that may be available. Helping with references or job hunting can make a significant difference.

Give the employee the opportunity to voice their thoughts and feelings. Be prepared to encounter a mix of emotions, from shock and anger to sadness. It can be a challenging moment for everyone involved, and it’s important to handle it with tact and sensitivity.

Leadership is not just about making tough decisions; it’s also about how you implement them. A little empathy can go a long way in maintaining respect and goodwill, even in the most challenging circumstances.

Termination is a challenging task that tests a leader’s management wisdom and decisiveness. By balancing empathy with professionalism, leaders can handle terminations in a way that upholds the dignity of the individual while maintaining the integrity and needs of the organization.

This article originally appeared in LINK, a newsletter produced by INTA’s Leadership Development Committee.

Although every effort has been made to verify the accuracy of this article, readers are urged to check independently on matters of specific concern or interest.

© 2024 International Trademark Association